Talk to any New Yorker and they will tell you the city is home to the world’s best bagels. But one Brooklyn man took it upon himself to figure out which bagels are best.

Mike Varley, a designer and computer programmer, spent 13 months visiting over 200 bagel stores across the five boroughs to produce EverythingIsEverything.NYC. The guide features Varley’s reviews based on the quality of the bagel, the cream cheese, and the atmosphere of the store.

“There are some bagels that are all the way doughy and that can be a lovely experience,” Varley told Shannan Ferry and Rocco Vertuccio Saturday morning. “There are some that are chewy in a way that’s challenging, but rewarding.”

P&C Bagels in Middle Village, Queens topped the rankings for Varley.