NY1.com

  80º

Updated 02/21/2009 04:11 PM

NY1 Theater Review: "The Story of My Life"

By: Roma Torre

  To view our videos, you need to
enable JavaScript. Learn how.
install Adobe Flash 9 or above. Install now.

Then come back here and refresh the page.

NOTE: "The Story of My Life" closes on Broadway on Sunday, February 22. NY1's Roma Torre attended the opening performance and filed the following report.

If there's any criticism I have for the unusual new musical "The Story of My Life," it's that it would probably be better served in a smaller, more intimate theater.

The 90 minutes without intermission are filled with just two actors and one set. But beyond size, it's a delicately-drawn ode to friendship, a lyrical poem really that feels so deeply personal, it runs the risk of getting swallowed up in a big Broadway house.

That aside, this is an impressive collaborative effort that, despite its minimalism, has the power to pack quite an emotional punch.

The plot is simple. Thomas Weaver and Alvin Kelby have been friends since first grade. They share a love of books, and in particular the Capra film "It's A Wonderful Life."

But by adolescence it's clear that Alvin is different, a sensitive young man who just can't seem to fit in with his peers. While it's never stated, he is very likely gay. After high school, they part as best friends. Thomas goes on to college and Alvin stays behind to help in his father's book store.

Forgive the spoiler, but the show actually begins with Thomas struggling to write Alvin's eulogy. Their journey is told through stories in flashback, both spoken and sung. As the audience learns details of the unique bond that drives the friendship, viewers are drawn ever deeper into the characters' lives.

Partners Neil Bartram, who wrote the music and lyrics, and Brian Hill, who wrote the obviously Sondheim-inspired book, fine-tuned this work with a keen insight for those seemingly inconsequential moments in relationships that turn out to be magically momentous.

Bartram's lovely songs resonate on many levels, while Richard Maltby Jr. adds further dimension with his sharply-etched direction.

Will Chase as Thomas and Malcolm Gets as Alvin are exceptionally talented. So perfectly matched in ways both subtle and large, they deliver splendidly calibrated performances that are simply flawless.

"The Story Of My Life" is about as lean as a musical can get. Broadway-goers expecting more bang for their buck may be disappointed, but I found it artistically consummate.